Navigating the Maze: Pitfalls in Sealing a Criminal Record

In the journey towards redemption and a fresh start, sealing a criminal record can be a crucial step. It offers individuals the opportunity to leave past mistakes behind and move forward with their lives unencumbered by the stigma of past convictions. However, the path to sealing a criminal record is fraught with pitfalls and challenges that can derail even the most well-intentioned efforts. From complex legal procedures to unforeseen consequences, navigating the process requires careful consideration and expert guidance. In this article, we'll explore some of the common pitfalls involved in sealing a criminal record and offer insights into how to overcome them.

1. Eligibility Requirements

One of the primary pitfalls in sealing a criminal record is understanding the eligibility criteria. Each jurisdiction has specific laws governing who qualifies for record sealing, and these criteria can be complex and nuanced. Common factors that may affect eligibility include the nature of the offense, the individual's criminal history, and the passage of time since the conviction. Failing to meet the eligibility requirements can result in wasted time and effort, making it essential to seek legal guidance to determine eligibility before proceeding with the sealing process.

2. Procedural Complexity

The process of sealing a criminal record often involves navigating a labyrinth of legal procedures and paperwork. From filing petitions with the court to attending hearings and providing evidence of rehabilitation, the process can be overwhelming for individuals without legal expertise. Even a small procedural error can lead to delays or denials, prolonging the process and increasing frustration. Seeking the assistance of an experienced attorney can help navigate the procedural complexities and ensure that all requirements are met accurately and efficiently.

3. Legal Obstacles

In addition to procedural challenges, sealing a criminal record may encounter legal obstacles that can complicate the process. Certain offenses may be ineligible for sealing, such as serious felonies or crimes involving violence or sexual misconduct. Additionally, some jurisdictions impose waiting periods before an individual becomes eligible to petition for record sealing. Understanding these legal obstacles and how they may impact your case is essential for developing a successful sealing strategy. An attorney can assess the legal landscape and advise you on the best course of action to overcome these obstacles effectively.

4. Public Access to Information

Even if a criminal record is sealed, it may not be completely inaccessible to the public. In some jurisdictions, certain government agencies, law enforcement, or licensing boards may still have access to sealed records for specific purposes, such as background checks for employment or professional licensing. Additionally, sealed records may still be accessible to prosecutors or judges in subsequent criminal proceedings. Understanding the limitations of record sealing and its implications for privacy and employment is crucial for managing expectations and making informed decisions.

5. Unforeseen Consequences

Sealing a criminal record may have unintended consequences that individuals may not anticipate. For example, while sealing a record may improve employment prospects by removing a barrier to background checks, it may also impact eligibility for certain government benefits or housing assistance programs that require disclosure of criminal history. Additionally, sealing a record does not necessarily expunge it entirely, and law enforcement agencies may still retain copies of sealed records for their records. Considering the potential ramifications of sealing a criminal record and weighing them against the benefits is essential for making informed decisions about pursuing record sealing.


Sealing a criminal record can be a transformative step towards rebuilding one's life and moving past past mistakes. However, the process is not without its pitfalls and challenges, from navigating eligibility requirements and procedural complexities to overcoming legal obstacles and managing unforeseen consequences. By seeking the guidance of an experienced expungement attorney and understanding the nuances of record sealing laws, individuals can navigate the process more effectively and increase their chances of success. With careful planning and expert assistance, sealing a criminal record can be a pivotal moment on the path to redemption and a brighter future.

Need Criminal Defense Help?

For a Federal or Criminal Consultation, text me today at 1-617-905-1433 or use the form below for your consultation. I will offer you expert help and answer any specific questions you have about your case. I handle criminal defense cases throughout all areas of Massachusetts including Boston, Cambridge, Newton, Springfield, Quincy, Lowell, Worcester, Fall River and national for Federal matters.

Contact Information

Geoffrey G. Nathan Law Office
132 Boylston Street
Boston, MA 02116

Download my contact information

Get Driving Directions