In the realm of criminal justice, a governor’s pardon represents a form of executive clemency that can dramatically alter the future of an individual convicted of a crime. In Massachusetts, as in many other states, the governor holds the power to pardon individuals under certain circumstances. However, this process is highly selective, involves multiple stages of review, and is subject to strict eligibility criteria.
Below is an overview of how a governor’s pardon works in Massachusetts, including who may qualify, how to apply, what a pardon can (and cannot) accomplish, and how Attorney Geoffrey G. Nathan can assist in this complex process.
What Is a Governor’s Pardon?
A governor’s pardon is an act of clemency that fully or partially absolves an individual of the legal consequences of a conviction. In practical terms, it can restore certain rights that may have been lost due to the conviction, such as the right to vote (though this right is already largely retained in Massachusetts), hold public office, serve on a jury, or possess firearms. A pardon can also enhance a person’s employment prospects by officially recognizing their rehabilitation.
Pardon vs. Commutation
Although they fall under the umbrella of executive clemency, a pardon differs from a commutation of sentence.
- Pardon: Typically grants forgiveness for the crime, effectively removing penalties and restoring rights.
- Commutation: Reduces or modifies the sentence of an incarcerated individual without fully forgiving the underlying crime.
Redacted Pardon Sample...
Legal Framework in Massachusetts
Constitutional Authority
The authority to grant pardons in Massachusetts is rooted in the state constitution. Article LXXIII of the Amendments to the Massachusetts Constitution vests the governor with the power to grant pardons and commutations, albeit with certain checks and balances.
Role of the Advisory Board of Pardons
Massachusetts law provides for an advisory board or similar body to review clemency petitions before they reach the governor’s desk. In Massachusetts, the Advisory Board of Pardons, which typically works in conjunction with the state’s Parole Board, reviews the applications, conducts investigations, and makes recommendations regarding whether a pardon should be granted. This process helps ensure that only those individuals deemed truly rehabilitated and worthy of clemency are recommended for a pardon.
Eligibility and Application Process
Who Can Apply?
Most individuals convicted of a crime in Massachusetts are eligible to apply for a governor’s pardon, provided they meet certain criteria. Generally, applicants must have:
- Completed their sentence (including any probation or parole requirements).
- Demonstrated evidence of rehabilitation and good citizenship.
- Complied with any waiting period specified by the state (which may require a certain number of years to pass after sentencing or release from incarceration).
Required Documentation
A typical pardon application may require:
- Personal Statement: Explaining the circumstances of the crime, the reason for seeking a pardon, and the evidence of rehabilitation.
- Character References: Letters from employers, community leaders, or family members attesting to the applicant’s good character and conduct.
- Criminal History and Sentencing Documents: Official court records detailing the offense, sentence, and any subsequent legal proceedings.
- Evidence of Rehabilitation: This may include proof of employment, community service, counseling, or other programs that illustrate positive change.
Review and Investigation
Once the application is submitted, the Advisory Board of Pardons (or an equivalent body) reviews the material. Investigators may verify employment, speak with character references, or even contact victims or their families to gather input. A formal hearing may be held to allow the applicant to present their case in person.
Governor’s Decision
After the investigation and hearing, the board provides its recommendation to the governor. The governor is not bound by the board’s recommendation but often weighs it heavily in the final decision. If the governor decides to grant the pardon, it typically requires the final approval of the Governor’s Council in Massachusetts.
Effects and Limitations of a Pardon
Benefits
- Restoration of Rights:
- Civil Rights: A pardon can restore certain civil rights, such as the ability to hold public office or serve on a jury.
- Second Amendment Rights: In many cases, regaining the right to possess firearms after a felony conviction can be contingent on a pardon (subject to federal restrictions).
- Immigration Considerations: While a pardon does not automatically resolve immigration issues, it may positively influence immigration proceedings by reducing certain grounds of removability or inadmissibility, depending on the specific circumstances.
- Employment Opportunities: Many private and public employers view a pardon as an acknowledgment of rehabilitation, improving job prospects and reducing the stigma of a criminal conviction.
- Social Standing: A pardon can lessen the societal stigma associated with a criminal conviction, helping the individual reintegrate into the community more smoothly.
Limitations
- Does Not Erase the Record Entirely: While a pardon forgives the crime, it does not necessarily expunge the record. The conviction may still appear on some background checks, although the pardon can be noted.
- Federal Crimes Excluded: The governor’s pardon power does not extend to federal crimes, which fall under presidential clemency.
- Discretionary Decision: The governor can deny a pardon for any reason, and there is no formal appeals process for a denied pardon application.
How Attorney Geoffrey G. Nathan Can Help
Navigating the pardon application process is often challenging due to extensive documentation, multiple layers of review, and a rigorous evaluation of one’s rehabilitation. Attorney Geoffrey G. Nathan has extensive experience guiding individuals through complex criminal law procedures. He can:
- Assess Your Eligibility: Attorney Nathan will review your background, court records, and personal circumstances to determine if you meet the criteria for a pardon.
- Prepare a Compelling Application: Crafting a persuasive narrative of rehabilitation is critical. Attorney Nathan can help gather the necessary documents—such as character references, employment verification, and evidence of community involvement—while also organizing a strong personal statement.
- Represent You in Hearings: If a hearing is held by the Advisory Board of Pardons or any other body, Attorney Nathan can advocate on your behalf, presenting your case effectively and addressing any concerns that may arise.
- Ensure Procedural Compliance: Failing to meet deadlines or format requirements can derail a pardon application. Attorney Nathan’s meticulous approach helps ensure that all procedural mandates are satisfied.
- Advocate for You Before the Governor’s Council: Should the governor approve your pardon application, it typically requires final approval from the Governor’s Council. Attorney Nathan stands ready to represent you in this final step, maximizing your chances of a favorable outcome.
Conclusion
A governor’s pardon in Massachusetts offers a second chance for those who have demonstrated genuine rehabilitation and wish to move forward without the burdens of a criminal conviction. While the path to clemency is complex and selective, thorough preparation and effective legal advocacy can significantly improve an applicant’s prospects. If you are considering seeking a pardon, contact Attorney Geoffrey G. Nathan to guide you through every stage of the process, from assessing eligibility to presenting a compelling case for clemency.
References
- Massachusetts Constitution, Amendment Article LXXIII. (n.d.). Commonwealth of Massachusetts.
- Massachusetts Parole Board. (n.d.). Clemency (Pardons & Commutations). https://www.mass.gov/orgs/parole-board
- Massachusetts General Laws. (n.d.). Executive clemency provisions. https://malegislature.gov/Laws/GeneralLaws
- Legal Information Institute. (n.d.). Clemency. https://www.law.cornell.edu/wex/clemency